I heard a talk about Sir Redmond Barry. The speaker came from an Irish background, so wasn’t pre-disposed towards Barry, who was of Anglo-Irish stock (as has been said, regarded as Irish by the English and English by the Irish). He regarded Barry as having been a harsh judge, with a strong belief in strong institutions, but paid credit to Barry’s work – consistently with his belief in strong institutions – in being instrumental in the founding of (what is now) the State Library and the University of Melbourne (he was the first Chancellor). Barry had a long-running relationship but wasn’t married, and fathered four children.
Of course, he is often remembered as the judge who sentenced Ned Kelly to death, along with Kelly’s retort to the effect that “I will see you there when I go” – and who died 12 days after Kelly was hanged.
Although I knew a little about Barry, the talk filled in a few gaps. However, I thought afterwards that, when assessing him, perhaps we need to take into account the times in which he lived. I suspect that he was by no means the only judge in that era who could be describe as “harsh”.